how to negotiate an insurance settlement for your car

Dealing with the aftermath of a car accident can be difficult, especially if you were injured in the accident.

It’s critical that you understand the basics of how to negotiate your auto accident settlement with the insurance company.

If the prospect of negotiating with your insurance company or that of the other driver is overwhelming, or an insurance company has refused to pay you a fair settlement, an experienced car accident lawyer may be able to help you navigate the claim negotiation and settlement process.

Even if you’ve never negotiated with an insurance company before, it is possible to obtain an auto accident settlement that takes into account all of your injuries, the pain and suffering you endured, and other losses like damage to your car and unearned wages. Car accident settlement negotiations aren’t much different from other types of negotiations.

There is one thing you must understand: The priority of the of the insurance company rep is to maximize profit, and they will therefore try to pay you as little as possible for your claim.

The tips below will set you on the right path towards negotiating a fair auto insurance settlement with the insurance company after a car accident.

Note: We strongly suggest that you speak to a qualified car accident attorney if you feel that your insurance company is not offering fair compensation. Most car accident lawyers, like us, offer free auto accident case reviews.

8 Auto Accident Settlement Negotiation Tips

  1. Initiate a Claim as Soon as Possible After an Auto Accident
  2. Keep Accurate Records About the Accident
  3. Calculate a Fair Settlement
  4. Send a Detailed Demand Letter to the Insurance Company
  5. Do Not Accept the First Offer
  6. Emphasize the Points in Your Favor
  7. Get Everything in Writing
  8. Know When to Hire an Attorney
  1. Initiate a Claim as Soon as Possible After an Auto Accident

  2. After a car accident, you should contact your insurance company right away. It is important to initiate a claim as soon as possible after a car accident so that you can recall details about your accident accurately and report any injuries or property damage that occurred. For more information on when to contact your insurance company after a car accident and what you should say, read our guide to contacting your insurance company after a car accident.

    Return to top ↑


  3. Keep Accurate Records About the Accident

  4. You should keep a file of records about your car accident that is organized chronologically. This file should include a police accident report if one exists, records of doctors visits, bills for car repairs, and anything else relevant to your accident. You will rely on these documents often during negotiations, and having them readily available can help expedite the settlement process.

    Return to top ↑


  5. Calculate a Fair Settlement

  6. Before you send a demand letter to your insurance company, you must determine what you believe your claim is worth. When arriving at a figure, you should take into account all of the following:

    • The cost of your medical care and related expenses,
    • The amount of income you lost as a result of your injuries if you were unable to work,
    • Whether you are permanently disabled or will require long-term medical care,
    • Any pain and suffering you endured after the accident, and
    • The cost of repairing or replacing your vehicle and any other property that was damaged in the accident.

    Based on this information, decide on a minimum settlement figure that you will accept. If you cannot determine what is a fair insurance settlement, a car accident attorney may be able to help.

    Return to top ↑


  7. Send a Detailed Demand Letter to the Insurance Company

  8. After you calculate what you think your claim is worth, send a demand letter to the insurance company. Describe the car accident, your injuries, the medical treatment you received, any ongoing health issues you have, how badly your vehicle was damaged, and any other losses you incurred as a result of the car accident. Then, tell the insurance company how much money you demand as a result of the circumstances. Because the insurance company will likely reply with an offer for an amount lower than what you’ve asked for in the demand letter, you should ask for between 25 and 100 percent more than what you would be willing to settle for.

    It is important to remember that you must have evidence and documentation to back up everything in your demand letter. A lack of evidence can prevent you from getting the offer you deserve.

    Return to top ↑


  9. Do Not Accept the First Offer

  10. When the insurance adjuster makes an initial offer, it may be too low. A first offer that is unreasonably low might be a tactic by the insurance company to see if you know what your claim is really worth. Ask the insurance adjuster to justify his or her low offer and give you specific reasons why your claim is so low. Respond to each of the points he or she makes in a reply letter explaining why you cannot accept the offer. Do not propose a lower figure – wait to see if the insurance company will increase its offer.

    If the first offer is reasonable but still too low, you may want to counter with a somewhat lower amount than you asked for in your demand letter. If you make a reasonable counteroffer, the insurance company will be more willing to compromise.

    Return to top ↑


  11. Emphasize the Points in Your Favor

  12. When communicating with the insurance company, emphasize the strongest points in your favor. Do not waste time going over undisputed facts, and focus on what’s most important to you. If you suffered an injury that will require lifelong medical care, discuss how this will affect your quality of life and finances over time. If you missed a significant amount of work, reiterate the total amount of wages you lost and how missing work impacted your family. Make it clear to the insurance company that you must be compensated fairly for your injuries and other losses.

    Return to top ↑


  13. Get Everything in Writing

  14. You should take detailed notes about all of your conversations with the insurance company. Ask that all settlement offers be presented in writing. If you reach an agreement, make sure that it is memorialized in a dated written contract that is signed by all parties to the agreement.

    Return to top ↑


  15. Know When to Hire an Attorney

  16. If you cannot arrive at a fair settlement agreement after negotiating with an insurance company, you may need to hire a car accident lawyer. An experienced accident attorney can help you evaluate your situation and determine whether a personal injury lawsuit is necessary.

Return to top ↑


Talk to an attorney about your car accident insurance claim

Sutliff & Stout are experienced car accident attorneys who represent clients who have been involved in auto, motorcycle, and truck accidents in Houston and the surrounding areas. For a free and confidential consultation about your case, text or call (281) 853-8446 anytime, 24/7.

Frequently Asked Questions About Negotiating An Auto Accident Settlement

Why should I settle my claim? Shouldn’t I file a personal injury lawsuit?

Most personal injury claims settle out of court because it’s faster, less expensive, and not as risky. Trials are also stressful, and it can take months for a jury to reach a verdict. After reviewing your case and settlement offers, your attorney will guide whether you should accept the offer or take the case to court.

How does the insurance decide to offer a settlement?

Claims adjusters will divide damages into physical damages, such as medical bills and property damage, and emotional damage, such as pain and suffering. The first offer may be a percentage of what they think is the final value. Insurers do this to pay out as little as possible.

Can I reject a settlement offer?

You can reject any settlement offer and respond with a counteroffer. Always send a typed and signed letter rejecting the offer and detail why you believe it should be higher. The letter includes how the accident happened, why the other party is responsible, and evidence of why your settlement should be higher.

How is my lawyer paid?

Most personal injury attorneys are paid on a contingency basis. If your claim is successful, they will take a percentage of the final settlement. The rate varies depending on the case type and attorney. If they do not win your case, you might not have to pay for their services. Regardless, you will have to pay court filing fees, witness deposition fees, and other charges.

Are you looking to maximize your settlement?

Studies show that people who retain an attorney are more likely to receive a larger settlement than those who negotiate with the insurance company on their own. Contact Sutliff & Stout today for a free, no-obligation case review.